Holmes Report Blog

The Holmes Report blog focuses on news and issues of interest to public relations professionals. Our main site can be found at www.holmesreport.com.

Tuesday, March 14, 2006

Reuters Gets Spun: Glenn Greenwald, a conservative blogger who really, really doesn’t like the Bush administration, picks up on a quote by Scott McClellan in response to calls for President Bush to be censured over his warrantless wiretapping (hat tip to Media Orchard). Said McClellan: “I think it does raise the question, how do you fight and win the war on terrorism?” McClellan said. “And if Democrats want to argue that we shouldn’t be listening to al Qaeda communications, it’s their right and we welcome the debate. We are a nation at war.”

No Democrat has suggested that we should not be listening to Al Qaeda. To the best of my knowledge no Democrat has argued anything remotely similar to that. But Reuters regurgitated the McClellan quote without comment or correction, and Greenwald argues that “no journalist ought to pass along this falsehood without pointing out that it is factually false.”

It’s almost impossible to imagine a mainstream media outlet allowing a Democrat to get away with the equivalent: “If the Republicans want to argue that they should be allowed to wiretap any American, even one with no connection to crime or terrorism, for no good reason except that they feel like it, that’s their right and we welcome the debate.” Such a quote would surely be followed by an explanation that that’s a pretty grotesque caricature of the administration’s position.

So is this media bias? Or are the Republicans just so much better at this kind of spin than the guys on the other side of the aisle?


  • At 10:18 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Why don't you ask the other Paul Holmes in charge of Reuters news?

  • At 8:35 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    If you locate the Reuters' editor, make sure he follows through with eradicating the spurious reporting about the "Captured" IDF soldiers in Aitaa-al-Chaab. They were snared on Lebanese soil. Even Pres. Bush wallowed in the untruths, live at a news conference yesterday (Monday 8/7/06). He referred to the "kidnapped" soldiers' being the cause of Israel's onslaughton Lebanon. When one's meglomaniacal leader spews lies how can either the Lebanese or the Palestinians get a square deal?


Post a Comment

<< Home